Regular and Substantive Interaction

Regular and Substantive Interaction

An Overview for Instructors of Online Courses at Saint Paul College

The U.S. Department of Education requires that all online courses for which students may use federal financial aid “ensure that there is regular and substantive interaction between students and instructors.” Regular and substantive interaction is more than a federal requirement, however. It is also a hallmark of effective teaching. Decades of research have established that teacher-student interactions are an essential component of learning. 

Characteristics of Regular and Substantive Interaction

Initiated by Instructor

To count as ‘regular and substantive,’ interactions need to be started by you. This doesn’t mean students should be discouraged from contacting you or asking questions – far from it! But you should expect to take an active part in initiating and guiding a range of interactions with your students throughout the quarter. This ensures that interactions are not optional and left up to each student’s individual discretion; rather, they are an integral part of your instructional plan for the course.
YES
  1. You post a discussion question and actively facilitate the ensuing conversation
  2. You ask a student to visit you during office hours or to schedule a phone call or videoconference with you
  3. You provide personalized comments (in any medium) for an individual student’s assignment
NO
  1. A student happens to drop in during your regularly scheduled open office hours
  2. You add numeric grades to the course gradebook
  3. A student submits a quiz that is automatically graded

Frequent and consistent

Interactions with students should be reasonably frequent and consistently repeated throughout the quarter. This means that once a course begins, long intervals of time shouldn’t pass between the interactions you initiate with students. The mode of interaction may vary throughout the course, depending on your aims and the needs of your students, but the regular cadence of interactions you establish should remain as consistent as possible. Daily communication isn’t required, but at a minimum you should be logging on and interacting with students more than once or twice a week.
YES
  1. You routinely post announcement or send messages that you have written specifically for the course
  2. You actively facilitate a required online discussion for every course unit
  3. You hold a required one-hour online review session every other week during the semester
NO
  1. You send a welcome message during the first week of class and a mid-semester message around week eight
  2. You encourage students to participate in an optional, one-time online review session before the final exam

Focused on the course subject

Interactions should be connected to the subject of the course and contribute to the students’ progress toward course, program, and college learning objectives. Routine procedural interactions, such as reminders of upcoming deadlines, aren’t ‘substantive’ on their own; neither are activities like assigning grades, unless they are accompanied by personalized feedback or suggestions for improvement. This doesn’t mean that interactions designed to welcome students or build classroom community aren’t important, merely that they aren’t sufficient by themselves.
YES
  1. You send a message previewing concepts introduced in the next unit and listing questions for students to have in mind when reading the textbook chapters
  2. You post an example from last night’s Twins game in the course’s ‘Real-World Physics’ discussion to illustrate the concept of coefficient of restitution
NO
  1. You remind students of the course attendance policy
  2. You post an announcement about an upcoming assignment deadline
  3. You post to the course’s ‘General Topics’ discussion thread lamenting the outcome of last night’s Vikings game 

Recommendations for Promoting Regular and Substantive Interaction in Online Courses 

There are as many ways to promote regular and substantive interaction online as there are approaches to teaching face-to-face courses. The following recommendations are general suggestions for incorporating interaction into your course, but you should freely adapt and personalize them to support course outcomes, the needs of your students, and your own teaching goals.

1. Set clear expectations for interaction in the syllabus

The syllabus is a good place to tell your students how you’ll communicate with them as well as how you expect them to communicate with you. Let students know how frequently they can expect to hear from you, when you will or will not be available to respond to messages, and how quickly they can expect a response to questions and to work they submit. If you have participation expectations for your students, be sure to include those as well—especially if they affect students’ grades.

2. Send course announcements or other messages at regular intervals throughout the semester

Announcements often focus on procedural information, like reminders of course deadlines, but they can also be used to support instruction. For instance, a weekly announcement can: synthesize and then comment on questions from the previous week; note trends observed in assignments; or highlight, contextualize, or illustrate key concepts students will encounter. Try to establish a general rhythm for course communications, using a pattern that is consistent with the structure or thematic organization of the course. Regardless of their frequency, announcements can be treated as genuine invitations into the subject matter of the course rather than mere reminders.

3. Provide timely, individualized, and in-depth feedback on student work

Research shows instructor feedback is most beneficial when it comes soon after students submit work, so avoid lengthy delays in providing students with comments about their progress. Feedback can take many forms: written comments, audio or video notes, individual conferences conducted in person or via online meeting tools, and so on. In all cases, though, feedback should go beyond simply assigning a grade or automatically displaying pre-written comments or general statements (‘good work’, ‘needs improvement’, etc.). Effective feedback communicates to students both what they have accomplished and areas where they may need to improve. It also often offers examples and concrete suggestions for actions students can take in the future to make further progress in their learning.

4. Actively facilitate online discussions and chats

A common misconception about online discussions is that instructors shouldn’t play an active role in facilitating them. While it’s true that a hands-off approach can be appropriate in some contexts, there are many benefits to facilitated discussions. Consider posting regularly to course discussion forums to: pose guiding questions related to the academic subject; propose counterpoints or alternative points of view that students may not be considering; establish connections among students’ ideas; engage in Socratic dialogue; and provide encouragement for students who may be struggling with the complexities of the subject. If the only voices regularly present in discussions are those of students, your course is missing a valuable mode of online instruction.

5. Choose online tools and learning environments that make interactions easy – and easy to document

When selecting online tools or platforms, consider carefully how they are likely to affect ease of communication for you and your students. When possible, select ones that help you document your communications. Email, discussions, chats, or the learning management system gradebook will do this automatically. 

[1] This document is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License.

Original created by Everett Community College



    • Related Articles

    • Fix Outlook Email for Android

      Fix Outlook Email for Android FIX OUTLOOK EMAIL ON ANDROID AFTER THE DECEMBER TRANSITION OF OFFICE365 On or after December 19, you will need to delete and recreate your account in Outlook on your Android devices. NOTE: ILLUSTRATIONS AND INSTRUCTIONS ...
    • How do I reset my course or delete all data in my course in D2L Brightspace?

      Important: Resetting a course is permanent and cannot be undone! All course components and user progress data is deleted and not available in data sets. All activities, content, and course files are deleted cannot be restored using normal UI restore ...
    • Fix Outlook Email for iPhone and iPad

      Fix Outlook Email for iPhone and iPad FIX OUTLOOK EMAIL ON IOS DEVICES AFTER THE DECEMBER TRANSITION OF OFFICE365 On or after December 19, you will need to delete and recreate your account in Outlook on your iOS (iPhone and iPad) devices. ...
    • How do I Host Large Meetings on Zoom?

      What sort of invite should I send out? Create an agenda with links to each meeting and Embed the passcode in your link by copy/pasting the “Auto generated link”. This link allows one-click joining of the meeting without having to enter the passcode. ...
    • Strategies for Video Messaging online students

      With fully online courses it is often difficult to develop community among the class or to make the course feel personable to students.  One easy thing to incorporate that may help partially overcome these barriers is to send out regular video ...